Criss Cross Charge: Balance Batteries Like a Pro!

Understanding battery equalization is essential for maximizing the lifespan of energy storage systems, particularly in applications like electric vehicles and solar power installations. Battery Management Systems (BMS) actively manage the charging and discharging of individual cells within a battery pack, and a key component of this is cell balancing. Implementing the criss cross method of balancing charge, alongside industry best practices like those advocated by organizations involved in electrical engineering standards, contributes significantly to optimal performance and longevity for your battery setup.

Image taken from the YouTube channel Wayne Breslyn (Dr. B.) , from the video titled The Criss-Cross Method for Writing Chemical Formulas .

Mastering Battery Balancing: The Criss Cross Method

Battery balancing is crucial for maximizing the lifespan and performance of multi-cell battery packs, especially in applications like electric vehicles, drones, and energy storage systems. Uneven cell voltages can lead to reduced capacity, accelerated degradation, and even dangerous situations like overcharging or deep discharging individual cells. The criss cross method of balancing charge is a simple, yet effective, technique for equalizing cell voltages. This guide will walk you through understanding and implementing this method.

Understanding the Need for Battery Balancing

Before diving into the criss cross method, it’s important to grasp why battery balancing is necessary.

• Cell Variation: Even within the same battery pack, individual cells can exhibit slight variations in capacity, internal resistance, and self-discharge rates. These variations become more pronounced over time and with use.
• Impact on Pack Performance: The weakest cell in a series string dictates the overall performance of the pack. If one cell reaches its discharge limit early, the entire pack is considered depleted, even if other cells still hold a significant charge. Conversely, overcharging any single cell can lead to damage.
• Extending Battery Life: By maintaining equal cell voltages, you prevent overcharging and deep discharging, significantly extending the lifespan of the battery pack.

What is the Criss Cross Method of Balancing Charge?

The criss cross method, also known as "charge redistribution" or "voltage equalization," involves manually transferring charge between cells within a battery pack until their voltages are as close as possible. It's a passive balancing technique, meaning it relies on direct physical connection and doesn't use complex electronic circuitry.

How the Criss Cross Method Works: A Step-by-Step Guide

The method involves connecting cells with higher voltages to cells with lower voltages, allowing current to flow and equalize the charge.

1. Measure Individual Cell Voltages:
   • Use a multimeter to accurately measure the voltage of each cell in the battery pack.
   • Record these voltages clearly, labeling them according to their cell position (e.g., Cell 1, Cell 2, Cell 3, etc.). This ensures accurate tracking of voltage levels.
2. Identify High and Low Voltage Cells:
   • Determine the average cell voltage for the entire pack. This can be done by summing the individual cell voltages and dividing by the total number of cells.
   • Identify cells with voltages significantly above the average (high voltage cells) and those with voltages significantly below the average (low voltage cells). "Significantly" depends on the chemistry and tolerances of your battery, but a difference of more than 0.05V is often a good starting point.
3. Criss Cross Connection:
   • This is the core of the method. You will connect a high voltage cell to a low voltage cell using jumper wires. Crucially, ensure that the wires are adequately rated for the anticipated current. Using thin wires could cause them to overheat and potentially damage the batteries or create a fire hazard.
   • Polarity Matters: Always connect positive (+) to positive (+) and negative (-) to negative (-). Reversing polarity will short-circuit the cells and could cause severe damage or injury.
   • Duration of Connection: Monitor the voltages of both cells during the connection. The duration of the connection will depend on the voltage difference and the internal resistance of the cells. Typically, a few seconds to a minute is sufficient for a noticeable change. It's safer to make multiple short connections than one long one. Over time, experience will help you judge the ideal connection time.
   • Important Note: Disconnect the jumper wires before either cell reaches the average voltage. This prevents the cells from oscillating around the average and potentially overcharging the previously low-voltage cell.
4. Repeat and Monitor:
   • Repeat the criss cross connection process, pairing different high and low voltage cells.
   • After each connection, re-measure the cell voltages and record the changes.
   • Continue this process until all cell voltages are within an acceptable range of each other (typically within 0.02V of the average).
5. Final Measurement:
   • Once you are satisfied with the voltage balance, perform a final measurement of all cells to confirm that the balance has been achieved.

Safety Precautions

• Eye Protection: Always wear safety glasses to protect your eyes from potential sparks or electrolyte spray.
• Insulated Tools: Use insulated tools to prevent short circuits.
• Proper Ventilation: Perform the balancing in a well-ventilated area to avoid inhaling any fumes.
• Monitor Temperature: Keep a close eye on the temperature of the cells during the balancing process. If a cell becomes excessively hot, disconnect the jumper wires immediately and allow it to cool down. This indicates a potential problem, such as a short circuit or internal damage to the cell.
• Appropriate Jumper Wires: Use adequately sized jumper wires with secure connections. Alligator clips are helpful, but ensure they are firmly attached to the cell terminals. Loose connections can cause sparks and inaccurate voltage readings.

Advantages and Disadvantages

Advantages:

• Simple and Inexpensive: Requires minimal equipment (multimeter, jumper wires).
• No Special Equipment: Suitable for battery packs without built-in balancing circuitry.
• Effective for Small Imbalances: Works well for correcting minor voltage differences.

Disadvantages:

• Time-Consuming: Manual process, especially for large battery packs.
• Requires Monitoring: Requires careful observation and monitoring to avoid overcharging or deep discharging individual cells.
• Risk of Short Circuits: Inherent risk of short circuits if proper precautions are not taken.
• Not Suitable for On-Going Balancing: Doesn't actively balance the battery during normal operation.

When to Use the Criss Cross Method

The criss cross method is best suited for:

• Restoring balance to a previously unbalanced pack.
• Preparing a battery pack for long-term storage.
• Troubleshooting issues related to individual cell voltages.
• Situations where active balancing circuits are unavailable or malfunctioning.

This method is not suitable for continuous balancing during charge and discharge cycles. For those applications, a Battery Management System (BMS) with active balancing is required.

Video: Criss Cross Charge: Balance Batteries Like a Pro!

Play Video