Air Resistance: Conservative or Non-Conservative Force?

Understanding the nature of forces is fundamental in classical mechanics, a domain where entities like the Law of Conservation of Energy play a pivotal role. NASA, through its aerodynamic research, has continually highlighted the complexities of air resistance in simulations. Work-Energy Theorem, a crucial principle, dictates how forces impact the total energy of a system. This discussion explores whether is air resistance a non conservative force. And this inquiry naturally leads to a broader understanding of energy dissipation, especially regarding practical applications like optimizing vehicle design via computational fluid dynamics (CFD).

Image taken from the YouTube channel The Organic Chemistry Tutor , from the video titled Conservative & Nonconservative Forces, Kinetic & Potential Energy, Mechanical Energy Conservation .

Air Resistance: Unveiling Its Non-Conservative Nature

The question of whether air resistance is a conservative or non-conservative force often arises in introductory physics courses. Understanding the answer is crucial for correctly analyzing the motion of objects within the atmosphere. We will explore the concept of conservative and non-conservative forces, then apply this understanding to air resistance, clearly demonstrating why air resistance is a non conservative force.

Defining Conservative and Non-Conservative Forces

Before diving into air resistance specifically, it’s important to establish the fundamental difference between conservative and non-conservative forces. The key lies in the work done by these forces and its relationship to the energy of the system.

Conservative Forces: Path Independence and Potential Energy

• Definition: A force is considered conservative if the work done by it in moving an object between two points is independent of the path taken.
• Path Independence: This characteristic implies that only the initial and final positions matter; the journey itself doesn’t affect the total work done.

• Potential Energy: Conservative forces are associated with potential energy. This potential energy represents the energy stored within a system due to the object's position. Examples include:

  • Gravitational force
  • Elastic force (springs)
  • Electrostatic force

  The potential energy can be completely recovered as kinetic energy when the object returns to its initial position. For example, lifting a ball increases its gravitational potential energy, and dropping the ball converts this potential energy back into kinetic energy.

• Closed Loop: A crucial test for a conservative force is that the work done by it over a closed loop (i.e., starting and ending at the same point) is zero.

Non-Conservative Forces: Path Dependence and Energy Dissipation

• Definition: A force is considered non-conservative if the work done by it in moving an object between two points depends on the path taken.
• Path Dependence: Unlike conservative forces, the path the object travels directly influences the total work done. Longer paths typically mean more work.

• Energy Dissipation: Non-conservative forces are characterized by the dissipation of mechanical energy from the system, usually into thermal energy (heat) or sound. Examples include:

  You also like

  Cardiac vs Skeletal Muscle: 5 Vital Differences!
  • Friction (sliding friction, static friction)
  • Air resistance (drag)
  • Tension in a rope that does work.

  This energy loss is irreversible. Once converted to heat, it cannot be fully recovered back into mechanical energy to perform work.

• Closed Loop: The work done by a non-conservative force over a closed loop is not zero. It is always negative, representing the energy lost from the system.

Air Resistance and Its Characteristics

Air resistance, also known as drag, is the force that opposes the motion of an object through the air. Its magnitude depends on several factors.

Factors Affecting Air Resistance

The magnitude of air resistance is influenced by:

• Speed of the Object (v): Air resistance generally increases with speed. The relationship can be linear (proportional to v) at low speeds or quadratic (proportional to v²) at higher speeds.
• Shape of the Object: A streamlined shape experiences less air resistance than a blunt shape.
• Size/Cross-Sectional Area (A): A larger cross-sectional area results in greater air resistance.
• Density of the Air (ρ): Denser air provides more resistance.

• Drag Coefficient (C_d): This dimensionless coefficient represents the object’s shape and its tendency to disrupt airflow.

  The standard formula for air resistance is often represented as: F_d = 1/2 ρ v² C_d A

Air Resistance as a Friction-Like Force

Air resistance can be thought of as a type of friction, though it acts on objects moving through a fluid (air) rather than across a solid surface. Like friction, it opposes the direction of motion and converts mechanical energy into thermal energy.

Demonstrating the Non-Conservative Nature of Air Resistance

To solidify the understanding of why air resistance is non-conservative, consider two scenarios involving moving an object between two points A and B.

Scenario 1: Direct Path vs. Indirect Path

Imagine moving an object horizontally from point A to point B.

• Path 1: A direct, straight line from A to B.
• Path 2: A longer, more convoluted path between A and B.

Because air resistance opposes motion, the object will experience air resistance along both paths. However, the total distance over which air resistance acts is greater for Path 2 than Path 1. Since the force of air resistance acts over a longer distance in Path 2, the work done by air resistance will be greater (more negative) along Path 2.

• This demonstrates the path dependence characteristic of non-conservative forces.

Scenario 2: Closed Loop Example

Consider moving an object along a closed loop – starting at point A, moving through a certain path, and returning to point A.

• Since air resistance always opposes motion, it will act on the object throughout the entire loop, regardless of direction.
• Work done will always be against the motion. Hence, energy will be lost to air resistance along the entire path from start to end.
• Therefore, the total work done by air resistance over the closed loop will be negative (representing energy dissipated as heat). This is because air resistance is consistently working against the motion, converting kinetic energy into thermal energy.

This negative work done over a closed loop is a definitive indicator of a non-conservative force.

Table Summarizing Key Differences

Video: Air Resistance: Conservative or Non-Conservative Force?

Play Video